Leaking Adhered Manufactured Stone on Commercial Buildings
The purpose of this article is meant to show that the moisture problems with adhered manufactured stone installs are not isolated to residential construction. The installers are screwing up on commercial buildings just as bad–if not worse.
I was called to investigate leaking windows on this strip mall in February of 2017. The property management team was planning on having to caulk a few joints here and there to seal things up. They could have not been more wrong. What I found was a 14-acre complex that is so botched up it would make you sick to your stomach to think about. Just like residential homes with leaking manufactured stone, all of the flashing details on this complex had been omitted, and they were faced with a failed wall system that was rotting from the inside out.
Because this was a retail shopping complex, I wanted to keep the invasive testing to the outside of the building. People were trying to conduct day-to-day business, and they didn’t need me drilling and cutting through the walls while customers were around. I opted to take my samples from the outside, instead of through the walls on the inside. This worked fantastically and I’ll keep this method of testing as an option for homes as well.
Darkened Adhered Manufactured Stone Walls Mean Big Problems
This is a good lesson for everyone. When manufactured stone siding soaks up moisture, it gets colder and darker- just like almost everything else in the world. Remember, adhered manufactured stone is NOT waterproof. If you notice dark staining on your home around the stone siding, it is a sign that you have trapped moisture under the surface and the wall assembly. All masonry sidings (real stone, stucco, brick, manufactured stone veneer) hold moisture to some extent. If the installer does a good job of decoupling the moisture-sensitive stuff like OSB sheathing behind the adhered manufactured stone, things don’t get wet and rot. But, if you have read any of my articles, you know that this isn’t happening.
Missing Window Flashing & Saturated Manufactured Stone
Windows are usually a big problem in adhered manufactured stone wall assemblies when it comes to leaking. Rain pelts the glass and vinyl of the window (both materials that do not absorb water) and hundreds of gallons of water run down the surface and land on the window sill below. If your installer did not detail the flashings around this window perfectly, the water will creep and wick in behind the stone veneer. When the installer makes no attempt at all to stop the water from getting in around the window sill it doesn’t take long for the moisture to wreak havoc.
You can see the install of this complex was botched from day one. All the ‘installer’ did was screw a board to the face of the wall and slap the stone veneer up around it. That’s it. No flashing, no sealant, nothing. These guys have no idea what they are doing.
Thermal Imaging and Saturated Manufactured Stone
There is no denying that the use of thermal imaging (aka infrared) is a game changer in building science technology. However, I find it’s not much help during manufactured stone inspections, as the problems are typically much deeper into the wall assembly than the camera is able to detect. But there is always an exception…
This day was perfect for using thermal to ‘see’ what was happening. It had poured the night before, so everything was still really wet in spots. You can clearly see this in the colorful image below. This roofline is funneling the water right to the corners of the walls. Add in the fact that the manufactured stone was screwed up and that the frieze boards don’t even extend past the wall cladding, and you get a perfect storm of stupid design. This was doomed to fail from day one. How no one noticed any of these issues during construction is beyond my comprehension.
Moisture Testing Adhered Manufactured Stone
Drilling the manufactured stone for moisture testing can be tricky. It takes the perfect speed and pressure to not blow through mortar bed and the wood behind it. It’s even harder to do when the wall is wet and mushy behind the manufactured stone like a lot of them are. You must stop the drilling once you get into the plywood, but be deep enough you don’t hit the expanded lath behind the mortar bed. Doing so would give you a false reading with the moisture meter. It’s a balancing act that you must master in order to get accurate results with the testing.
Along with all the missing flashing details on the upper sections of walls, the base of the wall is, of course, missing the proper drainage and weep screed. All of the water that is getting behind this manufactured stone has no way to get out–beside leaking into the shops throughout the complex.
So now you have a multi-million dollar shopping complex that is falling apart in just 10 years. The sad fact is that there is no saving it. At this point, you must rip the bandage off and correctly repair these buildings or they will continue to get much worse. The big question everyone asks is who will pay for all this? It will likely cost several million to repair, and I guarantee no one is jumping up and down screaming ‘pick me!’
For the rest us who have bad days, and think the world is coming down on you, just remember, no matter how bad you think you have it, at least you aren’t the guy faced with this disaster.
Latest posts by Ben Hendricks (see all)
- Best of 2019! A Home Inspector’s Year in Review - January 12, 2020
- How to Choose the Best Roofing Contractor - December 10, 2019
- How Can I Age My Carrier Furnace, Air Conditioner, and Heat Pump? - November 21, 2019